Vitale Letter #240, October 26, 2002 Anne Vitale PhD, Editor
- archives of back issues
- Notes on Gender Transition
- subscribe@avitale.com.
- To unsubscribe send an empty
- email message to unsubscribe@avitale.com
- LEAD STORY --
'They cut school Friday to buy long-stemmed red roses. They ironed photographs of the young teen they now call Gwen onto white T-shirts and wrote ``R.I.P Gwen'' with soap on the windows of their cars.'
- Eddie (sic) Araujo remembered by loved ones and hundreds of supportive strangers
- Transgender teen harassed at school, friends say 17-year-old killed Oct. 3 had stopped attending
- Community Buries Transgender Teen
- Teen's sad Tale, Troubled years preceded attack
- Man says he didn't kill teen after learning of gender
- The Remembering Our Dead Project Mourns the loss of Gwen Araujo: 23rd Death in 2002, 25th since last Day of Remembrance
- Gwen Araujo Remembered, Rev. Penny Nixon Leads Services 10/20/02
- Bereavement Fund Created for Slain Transgender Teen.
- Also see --COMMENTARY Teen's death points to lack of tolerance
- ANNOUNCEMENTS
[1]USA: Oregon-- Event Announcement: Creating Change Conference [2] USA USA Gender March Committee to Meet at NGLTF's Creating Change in Portland Oregon. [3] CANADA AND USA--BENT ON CHANGE II CONFERENCE GENERAL INFORMATION [4] UNITED KINGDOM--NHS trust gives sex changes priority [5] United Kingdom--Transsexual Opens "Frock Shop" For Men In Brighton [6] USA: 7,500 show up for Outoberfest 'A chance to be comfortable' [7] USA New Jersey--Trial opens in slaying of transvestite [8] USA: Fly Life LEGISLATIVE ACTION [9] USA: Eugene Oregon--City hears testimony on human rights law [10a] USA Boston MA--Mayor set to approve transgender protection [10b] USA: Boston MA--Council OK's transgender bill --Vote would broaden rights protections BOOKS Etc.... [11] Look both ways ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT [12] Jazz singer, rappers, Iraq, French divas on today's menu COMMENTARY Teen's death points to lack of tolerance By Dennis Rockstroh San Jose Mercury News
- =========///============///========///======///======///==========///==========///==========
LEAD STORYEddie (sic) Araujo remembered by loved ones and hundreds of supportive strangersMercury News | 10/25/2002 | Eddie Araujo reme... http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/4370745.htm Posted on Fri, Oct. 25, 2002 By Dana Hull Mercury News After the service, Eddie's mother, Sylvia Araujo, handed out 17 envelopes with a live butterfly in each. The butterflies were released over the casket. They cut school Friday to buy long-stemmed red roses. They ironed photographs of the young teen they now call Gwen onto white T-shirts and wrote ``R.I.P Gwen'' with soap on the windows of their cars. Hundreds of young people from around the Bay Area attended Eddie ``Gwen'' Araujo's funeral service in Newark on Friday afternoon -- and most of them didn't know Araujo at all. While close friends and family squeezed into St. Edward's Catholic Church for the services, a spirited vigil took place outside and was so loud at one point that people inside the church feared that a fundamentalist preacher from Kansas had arrived to protest. But Rev. Fred Phelps, who said he would picket the funeral, did not show up. Three men are facing murder charges with a hate crime enhancement in connection with Araujo's death: Jaron Nabors, 19, of Newark; Jose Merel, 24, of Newark and Michael Magidson, 22, of Fremont. The two other defendants, delayed entering pleas. They are facing the same charges as Nabors. The three allegedly beat and then strangled Araujo, who they believed was a girl, after they learned Araujo's biological sex at an Oct. 3 party at Merel's home in Newark. Contact Dana Hull at dhull@sjmercury.com or (510) 790-7311. TopTransgender teen harassed at school, friends say 17-year-old killed Oct. 3 had stopped attending Top sunspot.net - nation/world http://www.sunspot.net/news/nationworld/bal-te.transgender27oct27,0,7451947. story?coll=bal%2Dnationworld%2Dheadlines Knight Ridder/tribune Originally published October 27, 2002 SAN JOSE, Calif. - Friends and relatives of Eddie Araujo say they understand why the 17-year-old who often identified himself as Gwen, Lida or Wendy was so uncomfortable at school that he stopped making an effort to attend. Faced with a complex web of other problems, Araujo lost interest in school and fell behind. By the start of this school year, which would have been his senior year, he had stopped attending school entirely and had given up on graduating in June. For years before his killing Oct. 3, friends said, classmates taunted the transgender youth for the way he dressed and the way he acted. "We used to walk home together in junior high," said Stephanie Baumann, a close friend, adding that he was routinely subjected to anti-gay slurs. "He had a lot of issues, and people always teased him." Normally, Araujo would have attended Newark Memorial High School, the city's main high school. The school has taken great pains to address the issues of tolerance and sexual identity this year. Newark Memorial Principal Jack Roach has announced over the school's intercom that he will not tolerate anti-gay slurs. On Nov. 8, the school will perform The Laramie Project, a play that chronicles the life of Matthew Shepard, a gay University of Wyoming college student who was beaten to death in October 1998. But the measures came too late for Araujo. Some Newark Memorial students have told teachers this week that they can relate to the suspects who are accused of beating Araujo to death. "I've actually had students say that they might have done the same thing," said David Bible, a 1992 graduate of Newark Memorial who manages its theater. "They've asked me, 'Wouldn't you have hit him too?'" Stunned by the killing, Newark school officials are stepping up their efforts to combat hate and at the same time comprehend a horrific crime that allegedly involves former students. Superintendent Ken Sherer said the school district will meet with city officials tomorrow to plan a community forum on tolerance. The district will also provide in-depth training on gender issues to teachers and students. And school trustee Eileen McDonald plans to visit Jaron Nabors and Jose Merel, two of the young men who are being charged with Araujo's death, in jail. "I knew these boys," McDonald said. "They all went to Newark Memorial. I want to ask them what we could have done to help, so that we can prevent this from happening to other kids. Then I'll feel at ease." By all accounts, Araujo was an at-risk student. He attended Snow Elementary and Newark Junior High School, but by the eighth grade he was struggling academically. He went to American High School in Fremont for the ninth grade, then attended Bridgepoint, a small alternative high school in Newark, for part of his sophomore year. "Eddie bounced around quite a bit," said Kurt Carter, the Bridgepoint principal. "He really wasn't involved in school. His attendance was always against him. He came to school only half the time." Araujo later transferred to Crossroads, the district's independent study program. But he was so far behind in credits that it was clear he wouldn't graduate on time. Teachers said that calls to Araujo's home were never returned. The Newark Unified School District cannot release Araujo's cumulative academic record because of confidentiality concerns. Sylvia Guerrero, Araujo's mother, said: "There was no support here for my son." "Eddie did not fall through the cracks," said Paul Clifford, a Newark resident who is an active member of PFLAG, or Parents, Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays. "He was forced into a crack. He was labeled as a kid who obviously wasn't going to make it. The counselors are not only not serving these kids, they are completely unaware of them." END © 2002 by The Baltimore Sun. Top
Community Buries Transgender Teen TopLas Vegas SUN: Community Buries Transgender Teen http://www.lasvegassun.com/sunbin/stories/nat-gen/2002/oct/26/102608641.html October 26, 2002 at 3:00:20 PDT By MICHELLE LOCKE ASSOCIATED PRESS NEWARK, Calif.- In a sunny parking lot outside St. Edward's Church, family members released 17 butterflies, one for each year of Eddie "Gwen" Araujo's life. Araujo was buried in women's clothing and make-up Friday at a funeral attended by hundreds of mourners. Araujo was beaten and strangled Oct. 3 at a house party, where police allege three men attacked him after discovering Araujo was a male. "Angels don't have a gender and he's my angel now. I know that he's safe somewhere where no one can hurt him," said Araujo's mother, Sylvia Guerrero, addressing the crowd. Two weeks after the slaying, one of the suspects led officers to Araujo's body in a shallow grave in the Sierra foothills about 150 miles east of San Francisco. One defendant has pleaded innocent while the other two have not yet entered pleas. All three face charges of murder as a hate crime. Activists in the often-ignored transgender community are marching and holding vigils, saying they don't want Araujo's death to slip into the shadows. "We can't let one of our sisters' lives go unnoticed," said Rachael Janelle Light, president of Transgender San Francisco. But Araujo's family has shown a reluctance to see the name Eddie Araujo added to the list of hate victims such as Matthew Shepard, the gay college student beaten and left to die on a fence outside Laramie, Wyo., or Brandon Teena, whose murder at the hands of men who discovered she was anatomically female was the basis for the Oscar-winning movie "Boys Don't Cry." Jaron Kanegson of the Youth Gender Project said activists sympathize with the family. "No one wants to be remembered because they got killed in a horrible way. That's not what you want for your family member. "I think one reason so many activists in this area are so sad and upset is because they do know people who've been hurt or been killed," Kanegson said. "I don't think that transgender activists are missing that this was a young person who was a person." For the funeral, there was a service for family and close friends Friday morning, followed by an afternoon service open to the public. Hundreds of people filed somberly past the open casket. The family said they felt Araujo would want to be buried as a woman and they honored that. Later, more than 700 people packed into St. Edward's for the funeral, many standing outside when there was no more room. "I believe that our lives are changed now," said Father Jeff Finley. "I believe, I want to believe, that we will be able to say to each other, `I appreciate who you are.'" On the Net: http://www.youthgenderproject.org Top
Teen's sad Tale, Troubled years preceded attack Top Mercury News | 10/26/2002 | TEEN'S SAD TALE http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/news/local/4374271.htm Posted on Sat, Oct. 26, 2002 By Karen de Sá Mercury News Most who knew her in the town of Newark called her Gwen, a bubbly kid who wore jeans and sneakers and spent long afternoons dancing to music videos and painting her nails with friends. She was a sympathetic ear for teenage moms, an expert on makeup application, a fun companion at the mall. But Gwen was anything but a carefree 17-year-old. There was alcohol and drug use. She had stopped going to school. She came home so late so often that her mother moved some of her stuff into the garage. And Gwen was a transgender teen, born a boy named Eddie Araujo, still with a male body. When that fact was revealed at a party on the night of Oct. 3, police say, three men beat and strangled the youth to death. Police say the men, who face murder charges with a hate-crime enhancement, then took Araujo's body 150 miles away and buried it in a shallow grave on an abandoned logging path near the Sierra foothills. ``He was willing to stand his ground and be who he wanted to be, and people aren't used to that much confidence,'' said childhood friend Jennifer Woods, 16. ``Ultimately, I think his strength killed him.'' On Friday, Araujo was buried again, this time surrounded by the love and compassion of people who knew him as Eddie and knew her as Gwen. In a casket adorned with butterflies, Araujo's slight frame lay in a lace blouse and padded bra, fingernails stunning in rainbow glitter. ``I wonder how many times Eddie cried in secret, wondering, where do I fit in?'' the Rev. Jeff Finley told hundreds gathered at Araujo's funeral at St. Edward's Catholic Church in Newark. ``Maybe we were not there enough for you, because we did not understand.'' >From Eddie to Gwen Maybe there were signs during boyhood, maybe not. Araujo was raised with three siblings by his mom, Sylvia Guerrero, a legal secretary. His parents divorced when he was 2, but 13 aunts and uncles and 32 cousins swirled through his life. A mischievous boy who hated oatmeal so much he would dump it under the table, little Eddie learned to cook breakfast himself, at age 7. He climbed trees and played in the neighborhood clubhouse. He had a guinea pig named Snuca, and lots of girls had crushes on the skinny boy with a smile stretching ear to ear. Between the ages of 10 and 14, Araujo and the family attended the Evangelical Free Church in Newark, which preaches a literal interpretation of the Bible. Araujo joined Sunday school programs and a youth study group. In middle school, he began wearing makeup. At age 14, he started wearing girl's clothes -- not dresses or skirts, but ``just normal girl clothes,'' his friends said. He corrected people when they called him Eddie, shooting back, ``It's Gwen,'' in encounters again and again to get others to understand what he felt. ``When he was a him, he was a very cute guy,'' said Araujo's best friend Julia Valenzuela, 15. ``When he was a her, he was really gorgeous. He looked like he was going ballroom dancing every night. He caught the stare everywhere we went.'' Paying a price Courageous as it was to live as Araujo felt, it exacted a toll. As his need to dress and act like a girl grew, the family left the church, his mother said. And increasingly, they would distance themselves from extended family. Uncles were too macho, Araujo told his therapist, and the taunts from kids at school that he was effeminate, which began even in elementary school, were growing unbearable. ``He was harassed all the time,'' said Tara Rodriguez, 16, ``especially by boys,'' Araujo was already looking beyond Newark, reporting to friends and family that he would go to Hollywood and be a makeup artist. He would make ``hella money,'' he said, but meanwhile his school attendance was slipping. High school was a patchwork of independent study and continuation programs. This would have been Araujo's senior year at Crossroads High School, but he never showed up. Araujo planned instead on a high school equivalency diploma. At home, the family struggled to sympathize, but Guerrero never turned her son out. ``I wanted to love and protect him,'' she said. Then, using a term of endearment for a boy, she said, ``I would say `Mijo, I'll call you Gwen when you have a sex change.' '' But in the meantime, Araujo's behavior grew more self-destructive, and his mother concedes now that she ``never understood the magnitude of his pain.'' He wanted acceptance, but he found little, Guerrero said. Employers refused Araujo because his legal name and physical appearance did not match. People offered Eddie their help, including Linda Skerbec, a therapist associated with the Focus on the Family ministry who had known the family for years and saw Araujo between the ages of 14 and 16. She said she was on the verge of persuading Araujo to ``move beyond the label'' of transgender and ``claim the sexual identity that matched his anatomy.'' Focus on the Family is a Colorado-based ministry that sponsors ``National Coming Out of Homosexuality Day'' and promotes ``reparative therapy'' to change homosexuals into heterosexuals. The practice has been condemned by the American Psychological Association. ``To me, Eddie was very much a male, a creative, sensitive male,'' Skerbec said. ``But I worried some. I knew that kids like Eddie could be hurt.'' More pain, greater risks Social researchers are only beginning to understand the hardships gay, lesbian and bisexual youth suffer from and how lack of acceptance results in self-destructive behavior. Studies show suicide rates and substance abuse at two to four times that of the general population. Even less is known about their transgender peers. For Araujo, the perfect facade was often just that, not a safe place to embrace a deeply felt identity. Guerrero said Araujo attempted suicide and drank more frequently. He had no job and wasn't studying. Friends told police he traded sex for beer and marijuana. Last month, Araujo was found unconscious in front of St. Edward's, just up the street from the modest duplex where he lived with his mother and two siblings. Guerrero collected her son, who had passed out after a night of drinking. But it wasn't unusual. He often wouldn't come home at night. Friends and family insist that she remained devoted through all the hard times and that Araujo felt loved. But survival as Gwen required increasingly complex calculations -- and as Araujo became sexually active, the risk also increased. On Oct. 3 Araujo went to a party with friends who knew him as Lida. Araujo, who was wearing a skirt for the first time in public, had taken along jeans as a precaution, thinking she might become too drunk and someone might look up her skirt. But she never changed. Police say Araujo was killed that night after someone at the party discovered he was anatomically male and told the others. Days later, investigators came to the Araujo home searching for clues to who might have done it. Amid the teen's belongings, they found a Harry Potter address book -- and the names that led to three arrests. Mercury News Staff Writers Lisa Fernandez, Yomi S. Wronge, Dana Hull and Matthai Chakko Kuruvila contributed to this report. Contact Karen de Sá at kdesa@sjmercury.com or (408) 295-3984. Top
Man says he didn't kill teen after learning of gender Top Mercury News | 10/24/2002 | Man says he didn'... http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/news/local/4356727.htm Posted on Thu, Oct. 24, 2002 By Lisa Fernandez and Matthai Chakko Kuruvila Mercury News One of the defendants accused of killing 17-year-old Eddie Araujo said he was angry when he learned the transgender teen was anatomically male, but said he did not kill the Newark youth. ``I'm innocent,'' Jose Merel, 24, of Newark, told the Mercury News on Wednesday evening during an interview at Santa Rita Jail in Dublin. ``I'm sorry for what occurred,'' he said, ``but I had nothing to do with it. I don't have a history of violence and I don't wish death on anybody.'' Merel, Michael Magidson and Jaron Nabors are each charged with murder and a hate crime enhancement in connection with the death of Araujo, who police say was beaten and stabbed at a party at Merel's home and then buried in a shallow grave 150 miles away near Placerville. According to the police, Araujo was killed because the men discovered that Lida, as she was known to them, was anatomically male. ``Sure we were angry,'' Merel said. ``Obviously she led us on. No one knew she was a man, but that's no excuse for anyone to hurt someone. I don't believe two wrongs make a right.'' Merel, however, would not shed light on what took place the night of the party, nor did he implicate anyone else. He said he could not talk about specifics until he had spoken to his lawyer. Merel also emphatically denied statements made by others to police that he may have had a relationship with Araujo, and he said he does not believe that Araujo had a crush on him. He also denied that anyone used drugs at the Oct. 3 party. Merel and Magidson, who gave separate interviews at the jail, both wore jail-issued yellow jumpsuits and are being kept apart at the jail. These were their first interviews since they were arrested last week. Magidson, 22, from Fremont, also said he would not discuss what exactly happened the night of the party or Araujo's death. ``I can't even say,'' he said, when asked if he was innocent, stressing that he wouldn't talk on advice from attorneys he had spoken with. Magidson did say, however, that it was a ``total surprise'' to see police coming to his home Oct. 16 when he was arrested. ``I didn't even know why they were coming for me,'' said Magidson, who was at the Oct. 3 party. Nabors, Merel's two brothers Emmanuel and Paul, Nicole Brown and Araujo also were at the party. According to police, Brown, who is Paul Merel's girlfriend, at some point during the party entered the bathroom with Araujo and revealed to the others that Araujo was anatomically male. Brown told police that Jose Merel threw the first punch at Araujo. Magidson, Jose Merel and Nabors, who was not available for an interview Wednesday and whose family declined to comment at the jail, are scheduled to appear in court today. No one else has been charged, and the district attorney's office has indicated that no one else is likely to be charged. Magidson, who was visibly despondent during the interview and at times trembled, said he was scared -- but the feeling surfaced when he was arrested, not before, because he had nothing to be scared about. ``After it's all over,'' he said, ``I'm sure I'll be ready to talk.'' He said that his family has been visiting him and bringing him reading material. ``It's the only thing that's keeping me going,'' he said. Merel said he also is scared. ``Yeah, I'm scared,'' he said. ``I might end up staying here for something I didn't do.'' He said he longs to see his girlfriend and 1-year-old daughter, Kayla, who live in Colorado. ``Before this happened, my life was straight,'' he said. ``I was on a good path. This sucks. I hate it. I wish I could be with my family.'' -- Mercury News Staff Writer Putsata Reang contributed to this report. Contact Lisa Fernandez at lfernandez@sjmercury.com or (510) 790-7313. Contact Matthai Chakko Kuruvila at mkuruvila@ sjmercury.com or (510) 790-7316.
The Remembering Our Dead Project Mourns the loss of Gwen Araujo: 23rd Death in 2002, 25th since last Day of Remembrance Top From: Gwendolyn Ann Smith <gwen@gwensmith.com> Date: Thu, 24 Oct 02 22:06:47 -0800 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE October 25th, 2002 Contact: Gwendolyn Ann Smith gwen@gwensmith.com The Remembering Our Dead Project Mourns the loss of Gwen Araujo: 23rd Death in 2002, 25th since last Day of Remembrance 17-year-old Gwen Araujo had lived largely as a woman since she was 14, and had indicated that she did desire a sex change at some time in the future. She admired singer Gwen Stefani, and took her first name as her own. Others had known Araujo as Lida, or Wendy. On October 3rd Gwen Araujo was beaten, dragged into a garage, and strangled before her body was transported over 100 miles to a remote part of Northern California. Why? Because her killers were upset after discovering that Araujo was born male. Gwen Araujo is one of 23 reported anti-transgender murders in 2002, and one of 13 such cases in the United States this year. Like Gwen Araujo, at least one person dies in this country at the hand of anti-transgender violence. As the case has developed, we have seen Gwen Araujo disrespected in newspapers and on local television, her desire to be seen as a woman forgotten in the desire to sell the news. This disrespect flies in the face of established journalistic protocols set up by the Associated Press. The Remembering Our Dead project calls for justice in the case of Gwen Araujo, and the hope that her killers are tried and convicted for their crime. We also call upon the press to again review their guidelines towards the treatment of transgendered people. We also call upon individuals to donate on behalf of Gwen Araujo through the Gwen Araujo Bereavement Fund. 100% of the proceeds donated will go directly to the family memorial fund. Information for donating by mail, by credit card (Visa or Mastercard) or for online contributions via PayPal to the Gwen Araujo Bereavement Fund can be found at < http://www.ntac.org/donation >. We would ask that all organizations that serve the transgender community consider a donation to this cause. We also encourage everyone to attend and participate in local Day of Remembrance events in your area on November 20th. This event is dedicated to Gwen Araujo and all those lost at the hand of Anti-Transgender Violence and Prejudice. Details may be found at < http://www.rememberingourdead.org >. Remembering Our Dead is a project of Gender Education and Advocacy, Inc. Top
Gwen Araujo Remembered, Rev. Penny Nixon Leads Services 10/20/02 Top Rev. Dr. G. Penny Nixon to Lead Services Affirming All Gender Identities of God's Creation Sunday, October 27th 11:00 AM Metropolitan Community Church 150 Eureka Street San Francisco San Francisco &endash; Rev. Dr. G. Penny Nixon will lead services on Sunday, October 20th at The Metropolitan Community Church of San Francisco (MCC/SF), 150 Eureka Street, at 11:00 AM in memory of Gwen Araujo, the 17-year-old transgender Californian who was murdered last week in what appears to be a hate crime. During the 11:00 AM service, an altar will be created to affirm all gender identities as the glorious array of God's creation. The congregation will stand in solidarity with and in memory of Gwen Araujo. Rev. Nixon will read a statement about Gwen Araujo's death calling on religious institutions to "come out" in support of gender identities and to renounce any religious teachings that fuel prejudice against gender expression. MEDIA: Media Representatives are Welcome &endash; Please Sign-in at Arrival CONTACT: Rev. G. Penny Nixon: 415-269-2259 or e-mail: revgp@aol.com "Find inspiration, hope and love in our community of acceptance," Nixon said. "This is a place, a house of prayer for all people, which honors all gender identifies and upholds people's authenticity in bringing their full selves forward." MCC San Francisco's congregation includes more than 550 members from diverse Christian and other faith traditions. <http://www.mccsf.org> *** BELOW IS A COMPILATION OF UPCOMING RELATED EVENTS *** ** FRIDAY, OCTOBER 25th ** (1) PRIDE March and Memorial, October 25 PRIDE!, a gay-straight alliance group formed by Fremont students in response to the murder of 17-year-old Newark transgender youth Gwen Araujo, has planned a March through Fremont and Newark on Friday in memory of Gwen Araujo. Friday, October 25, 4 p.m. The march/protest will begin at Fremont BART at 4 p.m.: 2000 BART Way, Fremont, CA 94536 The demonstration will be on the corner of Mowry and Alpsenross at 5 p.m.: 2086 NewPark Mall, Newark, CA 94560 BRING SIGNS, FLAGS, AND YOUR OPEN MINDS -STAY SAFE AND SMART! ******************************************* (2) Press Conference & Vigil in San Francisco, Friday, October 25, at 6:00 p.m. A press conference followed by a candlelight vigil will take place in front of The LBGT Center in San Francisco, Friday, October 25 at 6:00PM. The Center is located at: 1800 Market Street - San Francisco, CA (415) 865-5555. ********************************************* (3) Sharing Circle in Hayward, Friday, October 25, 7 p.m. The Lighthouse LGBTQ Community Center will hold a Sharing Circle, in Memory of Eddie Gwen Araujo. All are welcome to express what this hate crime has stirred in them. When: Friday, October 25, 7-10 p.m. Where: The Lighthouse LGBTQ Community Center 1217 "A" Street (near corner of "A" and 2nd Sts., next to pink awning of "A" St. Cafe), Hayward (park on street or in BOA parking lot across "A" Street) For more information: Christina Cappelletti 510/247-8217 ********************************************* ** SATURDAY, OCTOBER 26th ** (1) Candlelight Vigil in Palo Alto, Saturday, October 26, at 6:00 p.m. There will be a candlelight vigil outside city hall in Palo Alto in honor of Gwen Araujo, a transgender person who was murdered in Newark on Oct. 3. Come and show your support. There will be speakers and some candles provided. Please bring extra candles if you can. Date: Saturday, October 26 Where: 250 Hamilton Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301 Time: 6-7pm What: speakers and candle vigil What to bring: friends, relatives, yourselves and a sweater for more information, email Elle Stacy at elle@gsanetwork.org, Gunn High School GSA, Palo Alto ********************************************* (2) CUAV Community United Against Violence Event - Oct.26 The night is dedicated to the memory of Gwen Araujo. Date: October 25, 2002 Time: 7:30 pm Location: Mission High School 3750 18th Street, San Francisco Description: "And the Movement Continues..." CUAV event and fundraiser, with rock and hip hop performances, including a special performance by Deborah Iyall. Tickets available from CUAV at (415) 777-5500. Contact: Tina D'Elia, (415) 777-5500 ex 304 ********************************************* ** TUESDAY, OCTOBER 29th ** Date: October 29, 2002 Time: 7:30 pm Location: The United Way Building, Room 105 1922 The Alameda, San Jose Description: In response to the recent murder of Gwen Araujo, a local young 17 year old transwoman, the DeFrank Center and others are organizing a memorial/vigil and candlelight walk down The Alameda, and we would like to invite you to become involved in the ceremony. After the ceremony we will walk down The Alameda to the DeFrank Center carrying candles and placards with the names of LGBT youth that have been murdered. Contact: Rev Free, (408) 281-1284, mfree@sbcglobal.net ********************************************* ** FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 1st ** Service of Lamentation and Dedication, Friday, November 1, at 7:30 p.m. Date: November 1, 2002 Time: 7:00 pm Location: Proyecto ContraSIDA Por Vida (PCPV) 2973 16th Street, San Francisco HRC is sending this alert to its members in California. Below is a list of community vigils in memory of Gwen Araujoa, a 17-year-old transgender Californian who was murdered last week in what appears to be a hate crime. Araujo, from Newark, had been missing since Oct. 3, reportedly after getting attacked at a party when it was revealed that she was transgender. Media reports say that Araujo was found last Wednesday in a shallow grave near a campground in Placerville, 150 miles northeast of Newark, Calif., where the fatal assault occurred. Police officials have yet to determine the motive for the murder but believe it could be a hate crime. Three men have been arrested and charged with murder by "special circumstance," which can carry the death penalty under California law. The men charged are: Michael Magidson, 22, Jose Merel, 22, and Jaron Nabors, 19. A fourth suspect, Merel's brother Paul, 25, was released without being charged, according to USA Today. "I'm going to bury him in the prettiest dress I can find," Sylvia Guerrero, Araujo's mother told USA Today. "With make-up. His tombstone will say 'Gwen'." Seth Kilbourn, HRC's national field director, responded to the crime with the following remarks: "We would like to convey our tremendous grief to the family and friends of Gwen Araujo, who are dealing with this unspeakable and senseless act of violence. We are glad police have apprehended the suspects in what looks to be a hate crime of the most heinous magnitude. At HRC, we abhor the ignorance and hate that leads all too often to violence against transgender Americans." Event: This event is an opportunity for the community to honor our loved ones who have passed. Please feel free to bring **copies** of photos and/or other articles of remembrance to add to the altar. There will be food, warm beverages and sugar skulls to decorate as offerings. There will be a special honoring of Gwen/Lida (Eddie) Araujo as part of the evenings' activities. _____________________________________ ** WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 20th ** National Transgender Day of Remembrance, November 20 Event: Transgender Day of Remembrance Date: November 20, 2002 Time: 6:30 pm Location: Harvey Milk Plaza Castro and Market Streets, San Francisco Event: Starts at Harvey Milk Plaza with a candle light vigil and march to the LGBT Community Center, for a 7:30 pm speakout and memorial in the Rainbow Room. Contact: Gwen Smith, gwen@gwensmith.com Description: the fourth annual memorial for victims of anti-transgender murder, this year held in nearly 40 locations worldwide, and noting 25 murders since last year's event, including that of Gwen Araujo.
BEREAVEMENT FUND CREATED FOR SLAIN TRANSGENDER TEEN
- Top
The National Transgender Advocacy Coalition (NTAC), partnering with Remembering Our Dead has re-established the Bereavement Fund to assist the family of Gwen "Lida" Araujo. Proceeds from the fund will be turned over to a Memorial Fund established by the family, in Araujo's male name: Eddie Araujo Jr.
Araujo had been attending an informal party on the night of October 3, when she was set upon by at least three males who discovered her true birth gender. She was beaten to death, taken to the garage and strangled, then with hands and feet bound and wrapped in a sheet, she was buried in a shallow grave in a remote area 150 miles from her home.
As always, 100% of the proceeds will go directly to the family memorial fund. Information for donating by mail, by credit card (Visa or MasterCard) or for online contributions via PayPal to the Gwen Araujo Bereavement Fund can be found at http://www.ntac.org/donation/Top
ANNOUNCEMENTS
- [1]USA: Oregon-- Event Announcement: Creating Change Conference
- Top
Via: Lisa Mottet, NGLTF and Gender Advocacy Internet News (GAIN), Date: Oct. 4, 2002 Lisa Mottet writes: Greetings Trans Activists and Allies - Creating Change is going to be great this year! There will be tons of transgender and gender-related workshops, discussions, and caucuses on top of our all day Pre-Conference Institute on November 7, Gender Splendor, which will be focusing on issues important to and affecting transgender people of color. Creating Change is in Portland, Oregon, from November 7-10. The Gender Splendor Pre-Conference Institute starts on Thursday, the 7th, at 9:00am. The Conference ends at 1:30 on Sunday, November 10th. (Monday, the 11th, is Veteran's Day.) For those of you who don't already know, this year we launch the first-ever Creating Change Conference theme: Building An Anti-Racist Movement. The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force is firmly committed to addressing the impact of racism in this country and in our movement, and to that end, much of the programming, workshops, discussions will be oriented toward issues of racism both inside and outside of our communities. Our slate of transgender-themed programming is extensive. Our Gender Splendor day is coming together, with a planning committee including about thirty transgender people of color from around the country. On Friday night, there will be a gathering for transgender activists to get to know each other and network. A tremendous performance piece, B4T, by Imani Henry will also be performed on Friday, at 1:00 PM. Transgender-related workshops and caucus discussions cover a full gamut of topics including federal legislation, youth, healthcare access, genderqueer identities, and sex. This year, the Transgender Civil Rights Project has worked to create more opportunities to talk about the federal agenda than ever before, with one workshop being a discussion of the transgender federal agenda and another focusing on the best methods for lobbying for transgender inclusion at the federal level. NGLTF received over 300 workshop proposals for only 150+ available workshop slots. Our schedule is completely full; our conference director was unable to schedule many, many great proposals. In fact, we added additional workshop time slots in order to accommodate more workshops over our three days together. I hope that everyone will come to this year's Creating Change so that we may all learn about and from each other, as people, as activists, and as sisters and brothers in the movement. See you in Portland! (Complete registration and housing information for the conferences is on our website at http://www.creatingchange.org (including info about free community housing) and if you can't find something on the web, call the NGLTF Creating Change information number at (202) 639-6333.). Lisa Mottet Legislative Lawyer Transgender Civil Rights Project National Gay and Lesbian Task Force lmottet@ngltf.org (202) 639-6308 Read more about the Project at: http://www.ngltf.org/statelocal/transgender.htm Below is a listing of most of the programming relating specifically to transgender, gender, and intersex issues. Please be aware that things may change before the conference! PRE-CONFERENCE INSTITUTE Gender Splendor: Building an Anti-Racist and Diverse Movement for Gender Freedom and Transgender Equality This Institute explores the diversity of transgender experience, paying particular attention to issues affecting and important to transgender people of color. This Institute will focus on ways we can work together across our many differences and will provide attendees with a better understanding of the ways in which racism and transphobia intersect in our lives. Topics include non-transsexual and gender-queer identities, intersex issues, significant others, family, friends, and allies (SOFFA), and the impact of age, ability, race, class and immigration status. Innovative programs and projects that address these issues will be discussed. All people are welcome and encouraged to attend. GATHERING *Gathering for Transgender Activists (Friday evening) This gathering is for transgender activists and allies of every level - local, state, federal - whether you are new to activism or have been working for decades. Let's meet each other, learn about what others are doing, and make connections to help each other and ourselves in our collective fight for transgender equality. PERFORMANCE B4T (before testosterone) written and performed by FTM activist Imani Henry, is a multi-media theatre piece that intimately explores race, sexuality and gender expression through the lives of three Black, masculine female-bodied people. Through a series of monologues and video clips, B4T (Before Testosterone) portrays the realities of various gender and sexual identities-including "butch," "lesbian," and "transgender". WORKSHOPS/CAUCUSES/DISCUSSIONS *Marginalize No More: How to Incorporate the Needs of Transgender Communities of Color Into HIV and Other Healthcare Services Despite evidence of high HIV/AIDS infection rates among transgender persons, comparatively few HIV care and prevention programs exist to meet their needs. This interactive workshop will feature participants in a discussion of the barriers and challenges to delivering effective HIV and other healthcare services to transgender communities of color, and will identify strategies for enhancing services to transgender communities at the Federal, State and local levels. *Building a Federal Transgender Agenda What should the transgender movement be doing at the federal legislative level? Participants will hear differing opinions and then will engage in a collective discussion about the different options and priorities to achieve transgender equality at the federal level. This session is for transgender activists and committed transgender allies. *Lobbying for Transgender Inclusion in Federal Legislation Participants will first discuss and learn the most effective messages and stances to take in advocating for transgender inclusion at the federal level. Second, participants will practice a lobby visit with the goal of having a Member of Congress agree to explicit inclusion of transgender people in a piece of federal legislation. Whether you are a beginner or have plenty of experience, you will learn something at this workshop! *Transgender Victories and Challenges: The Policy Arena This year has been a mixed bag for transgender people in the policy arena. Activists have created great statewide victories like the New Jersey safe schools bill and the Hawaii human rights commission decision. We've also seen local anti-discrimination laws pushed to passage in large and/or diverse localities such as Allentown, PA; Dallas,, TX; Multnomah County, OR; New York City; and Tacoma, WA. But there have also been some setbacks, like the Minnesota decision and the Kansas marriage case, to name a few. We'll cover these things, and also take a sneak peek at bills that may pass soon and cases on the cusp of decision. *What Does the American Public Think About Transgender Issues? This workshop will deliver the results of the groundbreaking Transgender Polling Project conducted by the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) that was completed earlier this year with the assistance of a diverse group of Transgender activists from around the country. The results of this project provide useful data that will help activists to develop messaging to communicate the issues that face the transgender community to legislators and mainstream America. *Best Interests of the Child This workshop will present topics and discussion on the issues a transgender parent may face. Topics include custody and transition; what are the legal, social and/or psychological issues for trans parents rights, custodial and non-custodial; who is the mom?; who is the dad?; what about the children?. This workshop will include video clips from the Court TV case of Kantaras v. Kantaras. *Gender, Disability, and Medical Abuse This workshop investigates the parallels between the experiences of trans people and that of intersex people, but not through the lens of gender theory as they are commonly addressed. Instead, it attempts to explore alternative approaches to building a true intersex-trans alliance through drawing knowledge from the critical disability theory and disability activism that problematize the social construction of normalcy and criticize the abuse of power inherent within the biomedical model. *Gender Theory / Gender Politics (Part I and Part II) Are some genders "real" and others boy-dykes, bio-girlz, trannie-boys and trykes "artificial?" Is gender something we are, or something we do? Is homosexuality a fact of bodies, or a way of politicizing their pleasures? If Feminism is about women's political needs, then who counts as women? Identity politics, genderqueers, and problem of knowledge -- join a lively, low-impact look at what theorists like Judith Butler are saying and why it should matter to you. *Supporting Trans Youth: Allies 101 This interactive session will provide essential information for service providers and others who want to support trans youth. Topics include relevant terms and concepts, the transition process, the specific service needs of youth in transition, differences between issues/needs of transitioning youth and adults, messages from trans youth about what they want and need from us, and challenges and rewards of supporting trans youth. *First Stop the Harm: Intersex in the 21st Century A new medical protocol is being prepared by intersex activists. The revolutionary patient-centered protocol will dramatically alter the landscape for the future intersex births and the way they are treated within the medical community. The new protocol, already being adopted by progressive hospitals, dramatically changes the way intersex children and their families are treated within the medical community. It seeks to end early surgical intervention by replacing it with treatment within the psychological realm and with peer support. This workshop will introduce this new patient -centered protocol being prepared by ISNA. A comparison of the outdated concealment-based and the new, patient-centered protocol will be included to give attendees a basis on which to speak about the issues afterwards within their own organizations. Action items and a plan for activists to work with towards the implementation and adoption of the new protocol will be discussed. *Beyond the Basics: Transgender Workers Building Solidarity A look at contracts, internal union practices, and how the labor movement has dealt with LGBT civil rights concerns. We will hear about recent successes, do some concrete brainstorming, examine strategies for working to change union non-discrimination policies and negotiating transgender protections in the collective bargaining process. *GenderQueer Across Generations: A Continuing Dialogue This is an interactive session, for youth and adults to explore and create a space to dialogue across generations of GenderQueer folks, trying to figure out how we can work together to create a space for young people to lead in the movement for change in our community understanding of gender. What are the issues that gender questioning youth face and what are the issues that transgender, transsexual youth, and differently gendered youth face in our movement and our society, and how we can learn from each other. *GenderQueer Activism in the LGB Movement This roundtable will be a community dialogue space to discuss GenderQueer identity, organizing in the LGB movement, and looking at what some of our challenges and successes are, and where we go from here. *Playing Doctor: Renaming Desire - Trans/Non-Trans Sex The caucus will focus on sex between trans and non-trans people, and the fears, desires and assumptions about that sex. This will be an opportunity for people to gather and talk honestly about sexual attraction between and among trans and non-trans people and the political implication(s) of manifesting that attraction. We will talk about identities and gender roles and assumptions and the limitations of such. We will do all this and more in an atmosphere of openness and clarity. ATTENDEES: Please be aware that we will be using adult language in this caucus. *Gender-izing and Racial-izing Desire: How Do We Get Who We Want and What We Want? What does it mean to be queer, sexual and a person of color? Which words are used to describe us? Which words are words we would use versus what is attributed to us? In what ways have we been acculturated to think about desire and to think about gender and race in relation to desire? What purpose does that type of thinking serve? Who does it serve? How does oppression fit into our notions about race, gender, sexuality and desire? How do we reinvision a world where desire transgresses the realms of memory and lived experience? How do we redefine the language used to express desire? Please join us as we engage in a lively discussion on the intersections of race, gender, sexuality, desire and cultural oppression. ** People of color only ** *Breaking Down the Barriers Between the Transgendered and Non-Transgendered Lesbian Issues of sexism, transphobia and discrimination are occurring in the lesbian community toward the transgender lesbians. In this workshop attendees will articulate and weigh perceived issues, participate in discussion, and arrive at potential solutions. The goal is to gain an understanding of each other and determine an action plan to begin the process of improving relationships within the lesbian sisterhood. *Transgender College Students Transgender students are beginning to demand more from their colleges and universities across the country. In this networking session, we hope to bring together those people who are researching the experiences of transgender college students. We hope to share ideas, strategies, and findings that will enable participants to return to their institutions with a network of people who are willing to work together to make the lives of transgender students better. Top
- [2] USA USA Gender March Committee to Meet at NGLTF's Creating Change in Portland Oregon.
- Top
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE -
(Portland, OR) The Gender March on Washington Committee will hold its next planning meeting in conjunction with NGLTF's Creating Change 2002 Conference in Portland, OR November 8th & 9th. This will be the third planning meeting to organize the inaugural national march to be held in the fall of 2003 or the spring of 2004.
The meeting will be held at the Doubletree Jantzen Beach Hotel, the convention's headquarters, in the Pendleton Room on the lower level. In order to allow meeting participants the opportunity to take full advantage of the workshops, caucuses, and plenary sessions of the conference, the planning sessions will not begin until 9 PM each day. All conference participants and march supporters are welcome to attend.
For further information contact gendermarch@yahoo.com.
- Top
[3] CANADA AND USA--BENT ON CHANGE II CONFERENCEDate: Thu, 10 Oct 2002 10:05:41 -0700 (PDT) From: "J. M. Goldberg" <jgoldber@uvic.ca> Via Rica Ashby Fredrickson <rica@netaxs.com> From: LGBTQ Resources To: j.tate@utoronto.ca Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2002 PLEASE CIRCULATE! Building upon the successes of Bent On Change 2000: Rethinking Queer Issues on Campus and in Communities, the Bent On Change II Conference Steering Committee is pleased to announce Beyond Tolerance: Rethinking Queer Issues on Campus and in Communities for November 1 & 2, 2002. With joint leadership from Ryerson University, York University and the University of Toronto, Bent On Change II will explore the theme of Beyond Tolerance on Campus and in Communities. Tolerance continues to be the predominant response of the mainstream to challenges from oppressed and marginalized communities. Bent On Change II will explore problems associated with the politics of both intolerance and tolerance and will generate ideas about how LGBTQ-identified individuals, groups and allies can empower universities and communities to move beyond tolerance. Delegates from across Canada and the United States will gather to hear many presenters and keynote speakers Zahra Dhanani, Immigration/Human Rights lawyer and activist, and Queer theorist Rinaldo Walcott from the University of Toronto. Amongst others topics include: *Sex In & Out of the Classroom; *Risk, Representation & Resistance: Organizing in Black Queer Community; *Students Dealing with Marginalization; *Class Passing in the Queer Communities; *(Trans) People of Colour and Two-Spirit People: Fighting Racism & Transphobia & Homophobia In Our Community (open to People of Colour and Two Spirit People only). For Conference Registration and more information: Visit the Website and Register: http://bentonchange.tripod.com or Email: bentonchange@lycos.com TopGENERAL INFORMATION
[4] UNITED KINGDOM--NHS trust gives sex changes priority
icWales - NHS trust gives sex changes priority http://icwales.icnetwork.co.uk/0100news/0200wales/page.cfm?objectid=12313954 &method=full&siteid=50082 Wales Oct 26 2002 Darren Devine, The Western Mail AN NHS trust that has refused to take on any new couples for fertility treatment has declared sex change operations one of its top priorities. Sex changes, or gender reassignments, have been named as a "waiting list initiative" by the Conwy and Denbighshire NHS Trust for the next five months, giving them priority over other forms of treatment. The trust made the decision because consultant urologist Christine Evans is due to retire next spring and the trust wants her to complete her existing sex-change workload before she leaves. Trust chief executive Gren Kershaw said the treatment at Ysbyty Glan Clwyd, in Bodelwyddan, includes counselling and hormone replacement therapy over many months, and during this period the patient builds up a relationship with Miss Evans. He said it would not be in the best interests of the patient to allow another surgeon at a different hospital to perform the operation after such a relationship had been established. The trust also maintains those on the waiting list are suffering from a distressing medical condition and the operation is as valid as any other surgery. Mr Kershaw said, "Miss Evans only undertakes approximately five gender reassignments per year compared to almost 2,000 other urological procedures. "Miss Christine Evans is retiring in the spring. In order to ensure that all her patients, including gender reassignments are seen within the 12-month government requirement, we have arranged extra theatre time for her. This does not affect any other surgery within the trust where we are on target to treat all inpatients within 12 months. "Waiting list initiatives are commonly undertaken when demand outstrips the capacity of the hospital. These are extra funded lists." He said only the four people left on the waiting list for gender reassignment would be treated and no new patients would be taken on. But childless couples yesterday said they too suffer great distress, and since 1997 the North Wales Health Authority has refused to take on any more women for fertility treatment. Some couples who were receiving infertility treatment before the policy was introduced in 1997 are still having their treatment paid for by the North Wales Health Authority. Alex Jolly and her husband Simon, from Llanbedrog, near Pwllheli, were forced to pay for two courses of private fertility treatment costing £6,000 because the North Wales Health Authority would not fund the treatment. She said, "People who want a sex change will argue that it's a medical thing for them. But I don't see it as the same thing." Mrs Jolly, 34, who is a member of the infertility support network Child, added, "Some women are infertile through cancer. "And that is a medical condition and any form of infertility to a point is a medical condition. "Infertility has a massive effect on a woman psychologically. "But you don't get anything for it - there is not even any counselling. "I can't understand how they can say just because this surgeon only has a year left we will get everybody through. "That's great, but equally there are a lot of people that have been waiting many years for fertility treatment and they are no nearer getting it." Hospital insiders have complained that Miss Evans is being treated as a special case. They say that when other surgeons leave their workloads do not usually become "waiting list initiatives". Three of the four people waiting for a sex change are English, with NHS trusts from outside Wales paying for the operation at Ysbyty Glan Clwyd. Critics have suggested the trust is keen to protect the money it will earn from the operations and that this is the reason for prioritising Miss Evans's workload. But Mr Kershaw rejected this, saying money did not come into the equation and said Miss Evans is one of only a handful of UK surgeons able to perform the operation. Top
[5] United Kingdom--Transsexual Opens "Frock Shop" For Men In Brighton Top Date: Thu, 24 Oct 2002 From: "Claire Ashton" <claire@c-ashton.fsnet.co.uk> From: Anon. http://uk.gay.com/news/7167 for Gay.com UK 24 October 2002 PROMOTION A transsexual is opening up a 'frock shop' for men in the city of Brighton and Hove. 'Lacies' opens in Hove next week, and promises an array of outrageous outfits aimed at the city's transsexual and gay community. The shop also expects to attract clubbers and people looking for fancy dress outfits. Transsexual Sue Sheppard, who owns the store, told the Argus: "Brighton and Hove is buzzing at the moment. There is a gay and a transsexual community and we want to capture that market. Lacies is about being outrageous and providing items you can't get anywhere else". Clothes on sale will include extravagant gowns, maids' outfits, Victorian basques and body-hugging PVC outfits. There will also be artificial breasts, wigs of all colours and shoes up to size 15. The shop will also stock sex aids. Top
[6] USA: 7,500 show up for Outoberfest 'A chance to be comfortable' Top [thanks to Chris Purdom via religion] via Rica Ashby Fredrickson <rica@netaxs.com> Arizona Daily Star, October 13, 2002 P. O. Box 26887, Tucson, AZ, 85726 (Fax: 602-573-4141 ) (E-Mail: letters@azstarnet.com ) ( http://www.azstarnet.com/ ) http://www.azstarnet.com/star/today/21013OUTOBERFEST.html By Arek Sarkissian II, Arizona Daily Star In a day dedicated to simple things, families pitched blankets on the lawn, couples cuddled and old friends sipped a beer together Saturday at Reid Park. But the attendance of about 7,500 showed there's nothing simple about the success of Outoberfest, a community event for people gay and straight, which has grown from just 50 participants when it was first held 26 years ago. For Suzie Fisher, who attended with her two children and girlfriend Linda Brez, Saturday was a day to feel free. "We'll still walk down Fourth Avenue and have people say stuff," Fisher said. "This is a chance for us to be comfortable and see people we haven't seen in a while." The event has become such a tradition for Fisher's children that they counted down the days. "It's fun to see the drag queens and just be here," said daughter Chelsea Verde, 10. It's also fun, she added, to hang out with her mother's friends. Outoberfest is more families than drag queens these days - much tamer, Brez said, than it used to be. Some concerns about harassment after the first-ever radio promotion this year never materialized. "I know a lot of people were worried when they heard it," Brez said. "It might attract the wrong kind of people." Instead, organizers got what they wanted - one of the biggest Outoberfests ever. "We really tried to open it up for families," said Wendy Bailey, president of Tucson Pride Inc. "We want everyone to come out and have fun." For a donation of $5 per person, people got live music, beer at $3 a cup, free soda and plenty of choice in food, as well as 40 booths where political candidates and nonprofit organizations made their pitches. The Arizona Dust Devils Cycling team raised money to get to the Gay Games in Sydney, Australia. "Who else is going to work this hard at this event as I am?" team member Jeff Ofstedahl asked while pedaling a stationary bicycle. Valerie Lopez, who came to meet a gay friend from work, said the event provided some exposure to a lifestyle she believes is becoming more accepted. She attended with her two children. "They have so many questions that I can't answer," Lopez said. "And I work with them, but I was never friends with one like I am now," Lopez said. "This is a chance for everyone to learn." Bette Arnold attended the event with her daughter Lisa, Lisa's girlfriend and their child, 11-month-old, Shelby. Arnold has seen changes in Outoberfest through the years. "As more people have become more accepting, there isn't any more of that tension they had when I went in the past," Arnold said. . Contact reporter Arek Sarkissian II at 629-9412 or asarkiss@azstarnet.com. Top
[7] USA New Jersey--Trial opens in slaying of transvestite Top NorthJersey.com - Paterson http://www.bergen.com/page.php?level_3_id=57&page=5396587 Wednesday, October 23, 2002 By JENNIFER V. HUGHES Staff Writer After a woman on the street offered him $20 for sex, Carlos Camacho says he accompanied her home, took off his clothes, and waited for her to emerge from the bathroom at her Paterson apartment. But when she came out naked, Camacho said he learned that she was a he. "Do you think that would be a shocking development?" defense lawyer Greg Aprile said to jurors during his opening statement Tuesday in Camacho's murder trial. "Could you imagine the disgust a person who is not a homosexual might have? Do you think there would be some reason to have fear as well as anger? ... What other perversions might he be subjected to?" Camacho, 20, is charged with murder for allegedly beating, stabbing, slashing, and strangling Victor Pachas, a 43-year-old transvestite, about 4 a.m. on Feb. 25, 2001. Camacho, of Paterson, admits he killed Pachas, but Aprile said his client is not guilty of knowing and purposeful murder. Instead, Aprile said, his client was "driven by revulsion and fear." The attorney pointed jurors toward a finding of passion provocation manslaughter - saying the crime was committed in the heat of passion resulting from a reasonable provocation. Murder carries at least a 30-year prison term, whereas the sentencing range for the manslaughter charge is five to 10 years. John Latoracca, Passaic County chief assistant prosecutor, told jurors they can't let discomfort with Pachas' lifestyle color their view. "Victor Pachas was a human being and he did not deserve to die," Latoracca said. Pachas' lifestyle "is not an excuse, it's not a defense, it's not a legitimate basis to call this case anything other than what it is: murder." Latoracca pointed to the brutality of the attack as proof the crime was murder, noting that the apartment was literally drenched with the victim's blood. He also told jurors about a portion of Camacho's police statement, where he said, "'I couldn't control myself because he was screaming, and I knew if people heard the screaming I would get in trouble.'" On Tuesday, jurors also heard from one of Pachas' friends, who was with him at a nightclub before he met Camacho. On the stand, Alejandro Fernandez said he did not recall whether Pachas talked that night about hooking up with a stranger for sex. In cross-examination, Aprile pointed out that Fernandez had told that to police the day after the killing. Jurors also heard from other tenants in Pachas' Genessee Avenue apartment building, who said they heard loud noises and cries for help that night. Camacho was arrested six weeks after the killing when authorities found him in Puerto Rico, where he had fled the day after the crime. His sister turned him in, Latoracca said. Camacho told police he had been walking home that night, and heard someone call him over to a car, Latoracca said. The driver was Pachas, who wore a skirt, heels, and a wig, and was on a block of Slater Street that is known for male prostitution, Latoracca said. Once back at Pachas' apartment, and after Pachas came out of the bathroom, Camacho told police he got up to get his clothing, but Pachas "went" for his knife. Camacho told police he punched Pachas and then stabbed him. When the knife blade broke from the handle, Camacho pulled the bare blade out from Pachas' back and started stabbing and slashing him in the face, Latoracca said. Aprile also told jurors that once Camacho was confronted with the truth about Pachas, he initially got up to leave. "Is Mr. Pachas going to try to convince him to stay? Or is he going to try to force himself on my client?" Aprile told jurors. Latoracca said that some parts of Camacho's statement were self-serving. Camacho, who appeared in court in a buzz cut and sporting tattoos on his cheek and neck, is being held in the Passaic County Jail on $500,000 bail. The case, in state Superior Court in Paterson, is set to continue today. Jennifer V. Hughes' e-mail address is hughesj@northjersey.com END © 2002 North Jersey Media Group Inc. Top
The Village Voice: NY Mirror: Fly Life: I'm (... http://www.villagevoice.com/issues/0243/romano.php [8] USA: Fly Life Top by Tricia Romano October 23 - 29, 2002 A nurse in a latex dress, a dirty old man wearing a sailor's cap, several well-endowed women with nothing on but tittie tassels, and a male go-go boy wearing black hot pants, sheer hose, and stiletto heels&emdash;this was the motley crew assembled last week at the Slipper Room for a benefit performance on behalf of transgender drag king Antonio Caputo. Caputo was traveling with New York drag king Mo B. Dick as part of the Men of Club Casanova 2002 tour. When the troupe tried to cross the Canadian border&emdash;without work visas&emdash;they were sent packing to the U.S., but Caputo, who is German, was taken to jail in Cavalier, North Dakota, and put in solitary confinement for 10 days. He says that during his imprisonment, he was refused blankets and caught bronchitis. He was then transferred to an immigration detention center in Elk River, Minnesota, where he was jailed with female prisoners and referred to by his female (and legal) name. Caputo's supporters&emdash;including Dirty Martini, the World Famous *BOB*, DJ Adam, Dee Finley, Amber Ray, and the Dazzle Dancers&emdash;helped raise money for his legal fees and other expenses. Caputo was sent back to Germany on October 11; it is unclear when he will be allowed back into the country. In a recorded message from Berlin, Caputo said, "I'm glad this terrible vacation is over now."
LEGISLATIVE ACTION [9] USA: Eugene Oregon--City hears testimony on human rights law Top via Rica Ashby Fredrickson <rica@netaxs.com> Daily Emerald, October 15, 2002 University of Oregon, Eugene, OR (Fax: 541-346-5821 ) (E-Mail: ode@oregon.uoregon.edu ) http://www.dailyemerald.com/vnews/display.v/ART/2002/10/15/3dac29a883967 Speakers testified for and against a proposed domestic partner registry and changes offering protection for transgender people Jacquelyn Lewis and Helen Schumacher, Staff Writers Community members had a chance to voice their opinions to the Eugene City Council about proposed changes to Eugene's Human Rights Ordinance during Monday's public hearing at City Hall. Fifty-eight people signed up to speak at the hearing, and both supporters and opponents gave emotional testimony. The proposed changes include the creation of a domestic partnership registry for gay and unmarried heterosexual couples, as well as measures creating protections for transgender people. The new language contains guidelines allowing transgender individuals to use the restroom facilities of the gender with which they identify. Three complaints of discrimination regarding gender identity have been received by the City of Eugene since 1998, but city staff and commissioners say most complaints of this nature are not reported. Former University employee Dick Romm said the city should approve the registry. "It's the right thing to do," he said. "It really can't affect anyone negatively that doesn't want to be affected negatively." He said that all partners - gay or straight - should have the same privilege of "getting it in writing." The domestic partnership registry would allow couples who meet certain criteria to register with the city and obtain a certificate recognizing their relationship. To be eligible for registration, both people would have to be at least 18 years old, be unmarried and "live as a family." Couples must also not be related by blood kinship. Portland and Ashland already have similar registries. Eugene resident Bob Pearson said he hopes the city won't approve the Human Rights Commission's recommendations. "The Human Rights Commission wants to force its ideas of morality on the community of Eugene," he said. Jennifer Self, a 32-year-old psychotherapist, said both changes should be approved. "It creates safety for those who have a gender identification outside of male or female," Self said. Self said the proposal regarding restroom use was the most important aspect of the hearing and that the registry is purely symbolic. "It reflects the values of our city of human dignity and respect for all," Self said. "It's amazing how this comes down to a restroom, isn't it? We're talking about dignity." City Council will vote on the proposed amendments 7:30 p.m. Oct. 28. Top
[10a] USA Boston MA--Mayor set to approve transgender protection Top From Brenda Lana Smith R.af D. Mayor set to approve transgender protection http://www2.bostonherald.com/news/local_regional/gend10242002.htm by Ellen J. Silberman Thursday, October 24, 2002 Boston city councilors yesterday cleared the way for new civil rights for transgenders and cross-dressers, overwhelmingly approving a proposed new law banning discrimination in the workplace, housing and even public bathrooms. Transgender activists applauded the measure - expected to be signed into law by Mayor Thomas M. Menino. ``This is the first step in awareness that there is a transgender community, that transgender people should be treated with the same respect and dignity as everyone else,'' said Gunner Scott, a member of the Massachusetts Transgender Political Coalition, the group that drafted the legislation. ``People like myself, my friends, my community will have a fair chance to make something of themselves,'' said Scott, who was born as a female but is in the process of a ``transition'' to male and prefers to be called ``he.'' An administration source said Menino, a longtime champion of civil rights, will probably sign the ordinance, unless city lawyers find technical problems. The ordinance, sponsored by District 7 Councilor Chuck Turner of Roxbury, bans discrimination based on ``gender identity or expression'' in employment, housing, credit and public facilities. ``Gender identity,'' according to the committee report recommending that councilors pass the ordinance, ``is an individual's internal sense of self (man/woman) and `gender expression' is the external manifestation of that identity (masculine/feminine).'' The Boston Human Rights Commission would handle discrimination complaints under the new law. Turner called the ordinance the next logical step in ``establishing a society of human respect and decency.'' District 3 Councilor Maureen E. Feeney of Dorchester, who championed the measure as chairwoman of the Government Operations Committee, said the ordinance would clarify a confusing situation. ``If your expression is male then you should be using the men's room. If your expression is female then you should be using the ladies' room,'' she said. ``This is not frivolous. We are addressing something that already exists in our city.'' But opponents say the council opened an unnecessary can of worms, creating an opportunity for thrill-seekers and sex offenders to make their way into bathrooms and other public venues traditionally segregated by gender. ``I think it was a mistake to put it in the code,'' said Councilor at large Stephen J. Murphy, who had a meeting out of City Hall and missed the vote. ``I have concerns that people that may not be transgender but now that it's in the Boston City Code would use it to hang out in a restroom with the opposite sex.'' ``If I put on a dress and heels and lipstick, am I a woman?'' asked District 2 Councilor James M. Kelly of South Boston, the only member to vote against the measure. But Feeney said, ``We have people today who are not transgender who are out today molesting people in men's rooms and in ladies' rooms.'' Kelly said he didn't understand how you could protect what someone ``thinks'' about their gender. ``We're solving a problem that doesn't exist,'' he said, explaining that he was confused by a public hearing last month at which ``I could not tell who was a man and who was a woman. Where should they go (to the bathroom)? I don't know.'' If Menino signs the measure, Boston would become the 41st city to pass a transgender anti-discrimination measure. New York, Philadelphia, Dallas and San Francisco already have such civil rights laws on the books, as do the states of Minnesota and Rhode Island. END © Copyright by the Boston Herald and Herald Interactive Advertising Systems, Inc. Top
[10b] USA: Boston MA--Council OK's transgender bill --Vote would broaden rights protections Top Boston Globe Online / Metro | Region / Counci... http://www.boston.com/dailyglobe2/297/metro/Council_OK_s_transgender_bill+.s html By Alice Gomstyn Globe Correspondent 10/24/2002 he Boston City Council yesterday approved a measure to protect transgendered persons from discrimination, passing it over the vehement objections of Councilor James Kelly of South Boston. The ordinance, authored by Councilor Chuck Turner of Roxbury, would expand city antidiscrimination laws covering race, religion, sex, and sexual preference to include ''gender identity or expression.'' It now goes to Mayor Thomas M. Menino. While nine of the council's 12 members supported the move, Kelly argued that transgendered persons don't face discrimination in Boston. ''I don't know why we should be voting to prohibit something where there is no evidence that it exists,'' Kelly told the council during an indignant speech against the measure. He was the only councilor to vote against the resolution. Councilor at Large Mickey Roache abstained, and Councilor at Large Stephen J. Murphy wasn't present. Other councilors argued that the ordinance served a higher purpose - to raise awareness of the struggles faced by transgendered individuals. ''If this ordinance protects just one of those people, then we've done something right,'' said Councilor Maureen Feeney of Dorchester, chair of the council's committee on government operations, which supported the measure. Grace Sterling Stowell, executive director of the Boston Alliance of Gay, Lesbian, and Transgender Youth, praised the council's vote. ''I think this is groundbreaking and courageous on their part,'' she said. ''It sends the message to everyone in the city of Boston and beyond that discrimination against anyone based on who they are is wrong.'' This story ran on page B6 of the Boston Globe on 10/24/2002. © Copyright 2002 Globe Newspaper Company. Top
BOOKS Etc.... Top [11] Look both ways Boston Globe Online / Living | Arts / Look bo... http://www.boston.com/dailyglobe2/297/living/Look_both_ways+.shtml GO! THURSDAY Look both ways By Hayley Kaufman, Globe Staff, 10/24/2002 ere's a line you haven't stumbled across in Go! before: Hermaphrodites are hot these days. Truly, you can't open a newspaper or turn on talk radio of late without running into Jeffrey Eugenides, the author of ''Middlesex,'' an intergenerational saga revolving around inbreeding, cultural assimilation, and the games recessive genes play. Eugenides, however, isn't the only scribe exploring the dynamics of blurred gender, that dark, mysterious place where sex and socialization mingle and, finally, meld. Novelist Amy Bloom, nominated for a National Book Critics Circle award for ''A Blind Man Can See How Much I Love You,'' also examines the ambiguities of gender and sexuality, in her first work of nonfiction, ''Normal: Transsexual CEOs, Crossdressing Cops, and Hermaphrodites With Attitude.'' Bloom reads from and discusses her new book tonight at 7 at Simmons College Alumnae Hall. 321 Brookline Ave. For more information, call 617-876-5310. Top
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT [12] Jazz singer, rappers, Iraq, French divas on today's menu Top Around Town - Vancouver - canada.com network http://www.canada.com/vancouver/aroundtown/story.asp?id={242230FB-8B01-4E58- 969A-2104C49C7CE1} AROUND TOWN Katherine Monk and Marke Andrews Vancouver Sun Thursday, September 26, 2002 (SNIP) FLYING WITH ONE WING (Tani Tatuwen Piyabanna) Directed by Asoka Handagama. Starring Anoma Janadari, Gayani Sudharshani. If the measure of a given society's humanity is the way it treats its minorities, then Sri Lanka has a lot of work to do, according to director Asoka Handagama. Granted, this is hardly a news flash in light of the recent political turmoil, but Flying With One Wing represents the first time in the history of Sri Lankan cinema that issues of human rights and tolerance have been grafted on to a narrative about homosexuality. In this sophomore effort from Handagama, we enter the world of a young, butch, female-to-male transsexual who faces constant harassment in both her personal and professional life. When she-he finds spiritual comfort in the arms of a woman -- who is also suffering the slings and arrows of sexism -- the world closes in around them both. While the entire feeling of the film borders on sappy melodrama, there is an edginess to the whole exercise that keeps you guessing about what Handagama is really trying to say. This is clearly not just about two sexual outsiders, it's a subversive comment on Sri Lankan society in general -- its chauvinistic attitudes, conservative intolerance and repression of alternative perspectives. The fact the film was made at all -- and survived a censor board review intact -- means things are changing for the better already. Today, 2:30 p.m. Granville 2, Wednesday, 2:30 p.m. Granville 2; Wednesday, 6:15 p.m. Granville 1, Oct. 8, 7:15 p.m. Granville 5. Katherine Monk Top
COMMENTARY Mercury News | 10/26/2002 | Teen's death poin... http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/news/local/4374314.htm Posted on Sat, Oct. 26, 2002 Teen's death points to lack of tolerance Top By Dennis Rockstroh Mercury News The brutal death of Eddie ``Gwen'' Araujo, a girl trapped in a boy's body, is more than just another slaying. It's a sad commentary on who we are. Araujo is dead because of who ``she'' was. I call it a hate crime. And the killers weren't born filled with hatred for someone who is different. Some among us taught them to hate. You know who you are. You're the letter writer who called Araujo's death a ``seedy freak show murder.'' You're the Christian who hates. You're the Boy Scouts of America who make intolerance official policy. I could go on with this list, but taking on Christianity and the Boy Scouts is about all I can handle today. Christians who hate And I'm doing it because I am a Christian and a longtime Boy Scout and adult leader. I was trained in Christianity for 13 years including five in a seminary. I am a trained Boy Scout adult leader. I admire Christians and Boy Scouts and all the good they do. But they are institutions run by humans. And they have flaws. In our midst are Christians who hate. They are, in fact, anti-Christs because they preach the opposite of what Jesus Christ taught us some 2,000 years ago. The message of Jesus Christ was a simple one. A scribe once asked Christ what was the greatest commandment. He responded that they are to love God and one another. This is not complex. We do not need the writings and sayings of learned people to tell us what this means. Love one another. It is a principle of most religions. Shortly after the news of Araujo's death moved across the nation, the Web site of a Christian church in Topeka, Kan., issued these words in bold print in a press release: ``WBC (Westboro Baptist Church) to picket funeral of cross-dressing teen pervert Eddie Araujo -- aka Lida, Gwen and/or Milner Araujo -- in religious protest and warning: God is not mocked. God hates fags and fag-enablers. Ergo, God hates Eddie Araujo'' Love God and one another. The Boy Scouts are more subtle. But the message they send the world from Scouting headquarters in Irving, Texas, is one of intolerance. As I said before, I respect the Boy Scouts and would join and send my son again. But I would work within Scouting to end this intolerance. Boy Scouts stance Earlier this year, in response to many in Scouting who have sought a change, the Boy Scouts national leaders issued this press release: ``The National Executive Board of the Boy Scouts of America has reaffirmed its traditional leadership standards, as recommended by its appropriate committees. ``The board received three resolutions suggesting changes in leadership standards in order to permit avowed homosexuals to serve as Boy Scout leaders. ``The BSA reaffirmed its view that an avowed homosexual cannot serve as a role model for the traditional moral values espoused in the Scout Oath and Law and that these values cannot be subject to local option choices.'' BSA is one of the largest youth organizations in America serving more than 5 million young people ages 7 to 20. As I said, the Boy Scouts are more subtle. But the messages from WBC and BSA are the same. Intolerance. The death of a 17-year-old Newark girl trapped in the body of a boy will not be forgotten. There are enough enlightened people around to explain much better than I can what a transgender youth goes through. I just know that Gwen did not intend to be that way. It was something she struggled with much of her life. It was the way she was. And it led to her death. If we don't learn from incidents like this, one thing is sure. It will happen again Contact Dennis Rockstroh at drockstroh@sjmercury.com.
-----------------------------------------*****---------------------------------------------- - Disclaimer: The accuracy of any information presented herein cannot be guaranteed. The opinions expressed may not reflect those of the Editor, Anne Vitale PhD.
- Switching ISP or employer, and need to change the address on the list?
- Sign-off from the old address by sending a blank message with Subject
- line as "unsubscribe" to unsubscribe@avitale.com. Sign-up at the new address
- by sending message with Subject line as "subscribe <Your Name Here ".
- When contacting the Editor, please direct all email messages to editor@avitale.com
- Thank you for subscribing to the Vitale Letter, A free online news service. The primary focus of the Vitale Letter is to pass on bits and pieces of information about the legal, cultural and medical aspects of our lives. Most of what I will be passing on comes to me via the many professional bulletin boards I subscribe to. I will also post press releases, Letters to the Editor, conference announcements, and other items of interest to the transgender and transsexual community.
- Letters to the Editor and other items of interest should be sent to editor@avitale.com
- To subscribe, simply send me an email message at Letter@avitale.com with the words Newsletter Subscribe in the subject heading. To unsubscribe, place the words Newsletter Unsubscribe in the subject heading.
- copyright October 26, 2002